Last modified: 1997-09-03 by zeljko heimer
Keywords: yugoslavia | pan-slavene colours | bosnia and herzegovina | croatia | macedonia | montenegro | serbia | slovenia |
Links: FOTW homepage |
search |
disclaimer and copyright |
write us |
mirrors
See also: Yugoslavia
On July 3 James asked about a flag for Montenegro. I don't know
about a post communist flag but Whitney Smith's classic book on flags
gives a seperate flag for Montenegro that is the same as the flag of
the former Yougoslavia but with the order of the stripes changed
(red-blue-white instead of blue-white-red). Of course most of the
republic flags from that era were the state flag but with the order
of the stripes changed. However, since Montenegro has stayed with
Serbia it is possible that their current flag is the same as the old
but with the star removed.
It is interesting to note that, with the exception of Bosnia, the new
flags of the breakaway republics are the same as their old ones but
with new badges. In other words the stripes, or in the case of
Macedonia the field (red), remains the same while the star is removed
and replaced with another symbol.
Nathan Augustine 03-AUG-1995
In former Yugoslavia this (the permutation of federal colours) seems to be
correct assumption, but it is not. For example, Slovenian national flag
(white-blue-red) had and still has the same colours but it originates from the
middle of 19th century (it far predates any Yugoslavia). Regarding flag red-white-blue, this is Croatian national flag (used to be and it still is).
Andrej Brodnik 03-AUG-1995
Actually I was not assuming that the republics of the former
Yougoslavia were copying the federal flag. In fact I had assumed
that the flags of the republics and of the federation were all
derived from the pan-slavic colors that are also seen in Hungary,
Bulgaria, Czechia, Slovakia and Russia. The origins of the
pan-slavic colors, BTW was during the reign of Peter the Great, early
1700s (according to Whitney Smith).
Nathan Augustine 03-AUG-1995
In case of Yugoslavia and Slovenia in particular your explanation and
assumptions are incorrect. Slovene national colours originate from the
coat of arms of Carinthia: originally golden eagle with red claws on a
blue background; eagle later got a crown (Habsuburg put it there as a
sign of gratitude when Carinthian knights had helped to rescue Vienna
before Turks, I beleive) but changed colour into silver. From these
three colours, silver, blue and red, was also made the first Slovene
flag -- I believe sometime in fourties of previous century. In
conclusion, neither Slovene flag nor its colours per se have nothing
to do with Peter the Great.
Andrej Brodnik 03-AUG-1995
With all due respect to a much esteemed colleague of the vexophilic list, I
must point out that Hungary is in fact not a slavic nation, in spite of the
outcome of the war in 1919. Magyars and their language are not related, even,
to the Indo-European language and peoples, but find their origin among the
free and often terrifying peoples of the Steppe, such as Huns, Tatars and
Turks, and also among the indiginous peoples of what is now Russia -- the
Finns and Ogric people.
Moreover, the flag of Hungary is green, white, and red. There is no blue on it.
It is to be hoped, however, that the Magyar people will find a new age of
cooperation and co-prosperity with their Slavic neighbors, especially Croatia
and Slovakia, as the central European economic recovery continues.
Alex Justice 04-AUG-1995
Actually I was aware of the ethnic origins of the Magyars, my
mistake.
In stating that the flags of this region, eastern (mostly slavic)
europe, used pan-slavic colors, I intended to show a relationship
between the flags of the area, not to state that the colors were
chosen for their "pan-slavism" alone.
Each country that chose these colors did so for reasons
of its own and in accordance with its own traditions. However, the
point is that these colors are the predominant ones in the region.
Of the 12 slavic nations, half have red-white-blue flags. The
exceptions being: Poland (red and white), Romania and Moldavia
(red-yellow-blue), Ukraine (yellow and blue) and Belorussia (red and
white or the new/old red-white-green) and Bulgaria (red-white-green).
Each of these exceptions uses either two of the colors or a
variation on one of them, yellow is similar to white and green is
similar to blue. Ukraine is the most non-standard of the group using
only two colors and yellow instead of white.
I've excluded Hungary since they are not ethnically
slavic and Bosnia and Albania since they differ significantly in
their culture. The other nations that I consider (perhaps erroniously
or incompleatly) slavic are: Russia, Czechia, Slovakia, Slovenia,
Croatia and Yougoslavia.
The use of pan-slavic colors is similar to the pan-african colors
"taken" from the Ethiopian flag. Each country that has these colors
has them for their own reasons, and their own interpretation of their
meaning. They also often add additional colors or change one of the
colors to one that is similar and more in keeping with their own traditions.
Several Carribian nations have also chosen these colors because of
their cultural affinity with Africa (eg. Jamaica and Guyana).
I did not intend to slight either Slovenia or Hungary or their
traditions/ethnic origins. I had intended only to point out a
trend that I had noticed.
Nathan Augustine 04-AUG-1995